Tripura RTI penalty: Officer fined ₹25,000 for blocking Chakma law info
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
The Tripura Chief Information Commissioner Binoy Shankar Mishra has imposed the maximum statutory penalty of ₹25,000 on S. Prabhu, Additional Secretary of the Tribal Welfare Department, for unlawfully denying information sought under the Right to Information (RTI) Act concerning the Chakma Customary Laws Act, 2022. The order, issued on 19 November 2026, marks a significant accountability ruling in Agartala, Tripura.
Background: The RTI Application
The case originated from an RTI application filed in August 2023 by Jagdish Rawat, Office Secretary of the Chakma Development Foundation of India (CDFI). Rawat had sought copies of communications, departmental opinions, representations from Chakma organisations, and certified copies related to the Chakma Customary Laws Act. The request was rejected by S. Prabhu, who was then serving as the Public Information Officer (PIO), on the grounds that the matter was pending before the State Legislature.
What the Commission Found
The Information Commission ruled that the denial was legally unsustainable, noting that no legislative privilege had been established to justify withholding the documents. In a particularly pointed observation, the Commission found that S. Prabhu had acted as both the PIO and the First Appellate Authority — effectively reviewing his own decision — a practice contrary to established legal principles.
The Commission further found that Prabhu had forwarded the RTI application to a private organisation, the Chakma Miley Jodha (Chakma Women's Association), seeking information from it. This transfer, the Commission ruled, violated the statutory framework governing access to information under the RTI Act, which does not permit routing public information requests to private bodies.
The Delay and the Penalty
The order noted a delay of 1,131 days in providing the information. Under Section 20(1) of the RTI Act, the penalty is calculated at ₹250 per day, which on a delay of this magnitude would have amounted to over ₹2.82 lakh. However, the same provision caps the total penalty at ₹25,000 — the maximum permissible fine — which the Commission imposed in full. The Commission stated that the officer had knowingly provided incorrect, incomplete, and misleading information to the applicant.
Significance for RTI Accountability
The ruling is notable on several counts. Critics of RTI compliance in tribal welfare departments have long argued that sensitive legislation affecting minority communities — such as the Chakma Customary Laws Act — is especially prone to opacity. This comes amid broader national concerns about PIOs misusing procedural grounds, such as 'pending legislative business', to delay or deny legitimate information requests. Notably, the Commission's finding that a PIO sat as his own appellate authority surfaces a structural conflict-of-interest that is not unique to Tripura.
The case also highlights the limits of the RTI penalty framework: even a delay of over three years attracts a capped fine of ₹25,000, a figure that critics argue is too low to deter wilful non-compliance by senior officials.
What Happens Next
The order directs that the information be provided to the applicant. It is not yet confirmed whether Prabhu has filed or intends to file a challenge against the Commission's ruling. The CDFI and Chakma community groups are expected to monitor compliance closely, given the broader legislative significance of the Chakma Customary Laws Act for the community in Tripura.